Home
Programs
Classes
About Us
Contact
Institute for Jewish Studies
Chai Hebrew School
Audio & Video
Weekly Torah Message
Donate
JDC Building Location
Archive
  
Chayei Sarah
Toldos
Parshat Vayeitzei
Vayishlach
Vayeishev
Mikeitz
Vayigash
Vayechi
Shemot
Va'eira
Bo
Beshalach
Yisro
Mishpatim
Terumah
Tetzahev
Tetzaveh
Ki Tisa
Vayakhel
Pekudei
Vayikrah
Shmini
Tazria
Passover
Last Day of Passover
Kedoshim
Emor
Behar
Bechukotei
Bamidbar
Shavuot/Naso
Beha'alotcha
Shlach
Korach
Chukat
Subscibe to Weekly Torah message

Home Hospitality 

If you need a place to spend the Shabbat call Rabbi Greenberg at 716-632-0467;
e-mail:rabbigreenberg@yahoo.com

Audio and Video 
Preview of the Institute for Jewish Studies

Va'eira 
 
THE THREE GUARANTEES

       After Moses complains to G-d at the end of last week's parsha why He had made things worse for the Children of Israel, G-d responds in the beginning of this week's parsha Va'eira with words of rebuke for Moses followed by His guarantee that He will redeem them imminently.

 

      "I revealed Myself to Abraham, to Isaac and to Jacob. I established My covenant with them to give then the Land of Cana'an. I also heard the moans of the children of Israel , whom the Egyptians are holing as slaves. Therefore, say to the children of Israel , 'I am G-d, and I will take you out from under the burdens of Egypt .'"

 

      Since these words were said by G-d in response to Moses' complaint that the process of liberation did not commence, we are to assume that in the foregoing verses G-d was supplying the reasons that Moses concerns were unfounded.  

 

      And as some commentators point out, if we carefully survey G-d's response to Moses we will see that He lists three reasons why He will finally redeem them:

 

      The first point G-d makes is that He appeared to the Patriarchs. The implication is that He had promised them that He would enslave their children and then liberate them. However, the reference to G-d's promise only appears in the next verse prefaced with the word "also." This implies that the first compelling reason for Moses to believe that the time of the Exodus has truly arrived is the simple fact that G-d appeared to the Patriarchs.

 

      What is it about G-d's appearance to the Patriarchs that dictated that the Jews would be redeemed?

 

      One answer to this question is that the Patriarchs were so devoted and faithful to G-d that G-d owed them the freedom of their children even if He had not promised it outright. If Moses had any doubts about the reality of the Exodus he could rest assured that G-d would not allow the children of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob to remain enslaved in Egypt .

 

      And it was also obvious that He would redeem them soon because, as our Sages tell us, if the people would have remained any longer in Egypt they might have never been capable of being redeemed. They would have degenerated so that there might have not been anyone or anything left to redeem. If not now, then never. The thought that G-d would allow the children of the Patriarchs to be lost was untenable.

 

      The second reason Moses could remain secure in the knowledge that the people would be liberated is the covenant He made with them. G-d promised. And G-d would certainly not go back on His word.

      The third factor or reason Moses, in effect, was given by G-d as to the inevitability of the freedom of the Children of Israel, and that it was imminent, was the fact that their suffering had become intolerable. Even if G-d had decreed that they would be slaves in a foreign land, the Egyptians went way overboard in afflicting them. There was no way G-d could allow this outrage to continue.

 

      In our own day and age we know we are so close to the Redemption because of the same three factors. And if we analyzed these three factors we will see that they reflect three distinct parts of our personalities: cold logic, faith and passionate emotion.

 

      Logic dictates that we should be taken out of exile:

 

      Our ancestors and forebears have done so much to sacrifice for Judaism and the Jewish people. How could G-d allow their work to have been an exercise in futility and all their sacrifices in vain? Sheer logic compels us to believe that the end is near; a time when all of our forebears' and ancestors' efforts will bear fruit. Especially now, when the forces of assimilation have so reduced our numbers and continues to undermine of future, is the argument so compelling. As one great sage of the past put it: "Moshiach must come soon, or else he will have no one to come to."

 

      Faith dictates that our Redemption is near:

 

      In addition, G-d promised through His prophets that He will bring the Redemption. Numerous Biblical and Talmudic prophecies that have materialized in our day coupled with clear pronouncements from contemporary Jewish leaders, particularly the Lubavitcher Rebbe, that "the time for our Redemption has arrived," all point to the fact that we are living in Messianic times.

 

      Our feelings also dictate that our loving Father in Heaven will not allow us to suffer anymore. We have suffered so much in exile. How could a loving G-d allow this situation to continue?   And while these words seemed to be phrased as a question, they are actually the cry of the soul of a caring human being. This "question" does not demand a philosophical answer. It wants nothing less than G-d taking us, His children, into His warm embrace. We feel it in our gut that our loving Father will not tolerate any more suffering on our part.

 

      This approach, as an intellectual argument, can be refuted, but it is intended not as a philosophical challenge as much as an appeal from the depths of our heart to the depths of G-d's "heart," as it were.

 

      One of the differences between an intellectual challenge to G-d and the venting of our emotions is that the former focuses on the past: "Why did this tragedy occur?" It is based on genuine intellectual curiosity. A human being is an intellectual and inquisitive creature. At the very least, humans possess an intellectual component that prompts them to ask questions.

 

      By contrast, the person whose question is an expression of his or her pain cries out to G-d for the future. "Please remove my pain. I cannot take it any longer. How much longer shall we have to suffer? I want a guarantee that it will not happen again," etc. etc.

 

      Another salient difference between the two forms of the question:

 

      When the question is of a philosophical nature one could be satisfied with an answer; the person who expresses his or her emotions cannot accept anything short of a total reversal of the painful condition.

 

      In summary, all three faculties of our soul: our logic, faith and emotions combine to forcefully argue and militate for an immediate end to the painful exile and the ushering in of the promised Redemption.  

Site Mailing List 
Learn. Discover. Experience.

The Jewish Discovery Center
212 Exeter Rd.
Wiliamsville, NY 14221
Tel: 716-632-0467
e-mail:yehoshua.greenberg@gmail.com


Institute for Jewish Studies 

NEW FALL 2010 SEMESTER

COURSE A --
THE FOUNDATIONS OF JEWISH LIFE: WHAT DO JEWISH BELIEVE?

5 SUNDAYS BEGINNING SUNDAY, OCTOBER 31 THROUGH SUNDAY, NOVEMBER 28 AT 10:00 AM – 11:00 AM

COURSE B --
COVENANTS: THE BIBLICAL COVENANTS AS MODELS FOR RELATIONSHIPS
5 SUNDAYS BEGINNING SUNDAY, OCTOBER 31 THROUGH SUNDAY,  NOVEMBER 28 AT 11:00 AM – 12:15
THIS COURSE IS REPEATED ON TUESDAY EVENING AT 7:00 PM BEGINNING TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 2

Classes 

INSTITUTE FOR JEWISH STUDIES

NEW FALL 2010 SEMESTER

For more details and to enroll click here http://www.gojudaism.com/institute.php


TWO NEW CLASSES FOR WOMEN

in memory of Mrs. Bella Greenberg of blessed memory

STARTING THIS SUNDAY, G-D WILLING, AT 8:00-9:00 P.M. AT

212 EXETER ROAD, WILLIAMSVILLE, 14221

First class, 8:00-8:30: Tanya: The Principal Work of Chassidic Philosophy

Second class, 8:30:9:00: The Jewish Concept of Moshiach and Redemption

Class can be seen live or archived on our website jewishdiscovery.org


EARLY MORNING TALMUD CLASS
MON. THROUGH FRIDAY AT 6:00 AM
At the home of Dr. Stuart Weinstein 59 Radcliffe Dr.

INTRODUCTORY TALMUD CLASS - MON. 11:00 AM CALL 568-1425 FOR DETAILS

LUNCH AND LEARN - Monday 12:15 PM - Law office of Cannon Heyman and Wiess,
726 Exchange Street
Suite 516. Call 716-632-0467 to confirm
LUNCH AND LEARN - Tuesday 12:15 PM Conference room, America 's Choice, 20 North Point Parkway (off N. French Road), suite 180 (call 632-0467 to confirm and for directions).

TALMUD-Mon, Tues, Wed., Thurs. 9:30-10:30 AM -212 Exeter Road

TALMUD - Mon. - Friday 6:00 - 6:30 AM 59 Radcliffe Dr.

WEINBERG CAMPUS - Torah study - Fri. 1:00 PM

BLVD. TOWERS - Torah study - Wed. 2:00 PM

TUTORIALS - in all areas of Jewish studies, for children, teens and adults - call 632-0467

Discussion Groups - Call 716-632-0467 for times, location and topic.

Hebrew Reading - Call 716-568-1425 for time and location


Programs 

Labor day picnic

The Jewish Discovery invites you to a Labor day picnic, Sunday, Sept. 5, 1:00- 3:00pm.


High Holiday Programs

ROSH HASHANA
Wednesday, September 8th
7:00 pm - Evening prayers - Welcoming the New Year


Thursday, September 9th
10:00 am - Morning Service
12:00 am - Shofar Blowing

Friday, September 10th
10:00 am - Morning Service
12:00 am - Shofar Blowing


Rosh Hashanah Feast
Start the year on a high note, join the Community Rosh Hashanah Feast!

Wednesday, September, 9th 7:30 pm

YOM KIPPUR
Friday, September 17th
7:00 pm - Kol Nidrei


Saturday, September 18th
10:00 am - Morning Services
12:30 pm - Yizkor Services
6:30 pm - Ne’ilah - Closing services
8:02 pm - Fast concludes & Havdallah
A light break-fast will be served


Music and Movement

Music and Movement By Rivky Greenberg

Tuesday and/or Wednesday mornings at 9:30 AM
Call: 716-688-1009


Chai Hebrew School 

Join the JDC's highly acclaimed
Chai Hebrew School
Click here for more info.
www.jewishtomorrow.com/
or call Rabbi Laizer Labkowsky
716-639-7600